An SSD State of the Union Update
I'm very pleased with the level of acceptance of SSDs today. When the X25-M first hit the market
and even for the year that followed, any positive SSD recommendation
was followed by a discussion of how many VelociRaptors you could RAID
together for the same price as one SSD. Now we have an entire category
of notebooks that come standard with some degree of solid state storage.
End users are much more accepting of SSDs in general, aided by the fact
that prices have finally dropped very close to the magical $1/GB marker
(a boundary I expect us to finally cross by the end of 2012).
Today's SSDs are not only more prevalent than those we were reviewing
just a couple of years ago, they're also a lot better. While the first
SSDs still had difficulties competing with mechanical storage for
sequential transfers, modern SSDs are several times faster even in the
most HDD-friendly workloads. The implementation of technologies such as
TRIM helps ensure the performance degradation issues of the very first
drives are less likely to be encountered by anyone with a normal client
workload.
Although it helped shape the client SSD business, Intel's drives are no
longer the only option for performance and reliability. There are good,
reliable SSDs from companies like Micron and Samsung that can easily
hang with their Intel competitors. And if you're willing to live on the
bleeding edge for the promise of the absolute best performance, there's
always SandForce.
The client SSD space may not be mature, but I'm happy with the current
state of things. With the exception of the ultra low price points, if
you want an SSD, there's a solution on the market for you today.
Going forward, I'm not expecting a ton of change in the near term. Intel's Cherryville SSD
has been delayed. This is the long awaited SandForce based drive from
Intel. I suspect the delay has to do with Intel working through bugs in
SandForce's firmware, but its efforts should hopefully make the platform
more robust (although it remains to be seen if any of Intel's efforts
are ported back into the general SF codebase).
In the first half of next year we'll see the first 20nm IMFT NAND
shipping in client SSDs. The smaller transistor geometry will
eventually pave the way for cheaper drives, although I wouldn't expect
an immediate drop in prices. At the very least we'll see firmware
updates enabling 20nm NAND support, although we may see the introduction
of some new controllers as well. We're going to be pretty limited in
terms of performance gains until ONFI 3.0 based controllers/NAND show up in early 2013. I expect the next 12 months to be more about driving enterprise SSDs and bringing down the cost of consumer drives.
The Topic At Hand: OCZ's Octane
Now for the reason we're all here today. Earlier this year OCZ acquired Indilinx,
one of the first SSD controller makers to really make a splash in the
enthusiast community. Ever since OCZ entered the SSD business it wanted
to guarantee its independence by securing exclusive rights to a
controller. OCZ initially did so by buying up all available inventory,
first of Indilinx controllers, then of SandForce controllers. That
strategy would only work for a (relatively) short period of time as the
controller vendors sought to expand their market by selling chips to
OCZ's competitors. A few slip ups on the roadmap and Indilinx was ripe
for acquisition. OCZ stepped up to the plate and sealed the deal.
Several months later, OCZ debuted its first drive based on an
unreleased, exclusive Indilinx design: Octane.
Although Octane didn't set any performance records, it was competitive.
Performance was definitely current gen, giving OCZ an in-house
alternative to SandForce. There was just one issue: OCZ only sent out
512GB Octane review samples. SSDs get a good amount of their performance
by executing reads/writes in parallel across multiple NAND devices.
Higher capacities have more devices to read/write in parallel, and thus
generally deliver the best performance. The greatest sales volume is of
the lower capacity models - they're cheaper to own and NAND prices are
falling quickly enough that investing in a 512GB drive rarely makes
financial sense.